10 products per page15 products per page25 products per page30 products per page50 products per page100 products per page

Sort by popularity Sort by latest Sort by price: low to high Sort by price: high to low

• View:
• 100
• 200
• All

• Quick View

  • Quick View
  • Everyday Bears

  • First & Main | White Teddy Bear with Red Ribbon
    Benny
    6″

  • $5.99
  • Adorable 6" Benny Bear from First & Main, white teddy bear with a red ribbon. Get yours today!
  • Add to cart
• Quick View

  • Quick View
  • Everyday Bears

  • First & Main | Assorted Teddy Bears
    Mac
    10″ | 2 Assorted

  • $17.99
  • First & Main introduces Mac, the assorted teddy bears. Available in a cute 10" size. Get yours now!
  • Add to cart
• Quick View

  • Quick View
  • Everyday Bears

  • First & Main | Brown Teddy Bear
    Buster Bears
    7″ | 2 Assorted

  • $25.99
  • Adorable 7" Brown Teddy Bear from First & Main, perfect for cuddles.
  • Add to cart
• Quick View

  • Quick View
  • Get Well

  • First & Main | Stuffed Animal
    Boo Boo Buddies
    6″

  • $49.99
  • Stuffed Animal by First & Main - Cheer up loved ones with these adorable plush animals.
  • Add to cart
• Quick View

  • Quick View
  • Valentine's Day

  • First & Main | Unicorn Plush
    Magical Unicorn
    7″

  • $12.99
  • First & Main brings you the Unicorn Plush. Standing at 7″, it's a perfect Valentine's Day gift.
  • Add to cart
• Quick View

  • Quick View
  • Valentine's Day

  • First & Main | Brown Teddy Bear with Heart and Rose
    Gus
    15″

  • $32.99
  • Discover Gus, a charming 15" brown teddy bear holding a heart and rose, from First & Main. Perfect as a gift!
  • Add to cart
• Quick View

  • Quick View
  • Valentine's Day

  • First & Main | Valentines Teddy Bear
    Boxer Bob
    10″

  • $22.99
  • Meet Boxer Bob, a cute 10″ Valentine's Teddy Bear in love-themed boxer shorts from First & Main.
  • Add to cart
• Quick View

  • Quick View
  • Valentine's Day

  • First & Main | Plush Animals
    XO Cuties
    10″ | 4 Assorted

  • $58.99
  • Discover First & Main's 10" Plush Animals - panda, bear, monkey, and dog. Perfect for snuggling and gifting.
  • Add to cart
• Quick View

  • Sale!
    Quick View
  • Bags

  • First & Main | Cork Bible Cover
    8″ x 12″

  • $10.00 Original price was: $10.00.$2.50Current price is: $2.50.
  • Eco-friendly Cork Bible Cover for stylish protection.
  • Add to cart
• Quick View

  • Quick View
  • Comforting Crosses

  • First & Main | Tie-Dye Pocket Cross
    3″

  • $9.99
  • This beautiful 3″ tall Tie-Dye Pocket Cross is a vibrant and colorful addition to any collection.
  • Add to cart
• Quick View

  • Quick View
  • Patriotic

  • First & Main | Patriotic Cross
    5.5″ Includes Gift Box

  • $19.99
  • First & Main Patriotic Cross, 5.5". Handcrafted with patriotic colors.
  • Add to cart
• Quick View

  • Quick View
  • Comforting Crosses

  • First & Main | Colorful Pattern Cross
    Tuscan Pocket Cross
    3″

  • $9.99
  • First & Main Colorful Pattern Cross with Tuscan-inspired designs, 3".
  • Add to cart
• Quick View

  • Quick View
  • Comforting Crosses

  • First & Main | Green Pocket Cross
    Multiple Blessings
    3″

  • $9.99
  • The First & Main Green Pocket Cross, designed by Caroline Simas, offers a comforting presence in a beautiful, compact form.
  • Add to cart
• Quick View

  • Quick View
  • FantaZoo

  • First & Main | Colorful Plush Sloth
    Fanta Zoo Selena Sloth
    7″

  • $10.99
  • First & Main presents the brightly colored Fanta Zoo Selena Sloth. 7" tall sloth plush and now available!
  • Add to cart
• Quick View

  • Quick View
  • FantaZoo

  • First & Main | Owl Plush
    Fanta Zoo Olivia Owl
    10″

  • $15.99
  • Adorable 10" Pink and Green Owl Plush by First & Main. Perfect for kids.
  • Add to cart
• Quick View

  • Quick View
  • FantaZoo

  • First & Main | Owl Plush Toy
    Fanta Zoo Olivia Owl
    7″

  • $10.99
  • Meet the vibrant pink and green owl plush toy by First & Main. This 7" stuffed animal features soft, cuddly textures and shimmering details.
  • Add to cart
• Quick View

  • Quick View
  • FantaSEA

  • First & Main | Narwhal Plush
    Fanta Sea Nahla Narwhal
    15″

  • $23.99
  • The 15" Fanta Sea Nahla Narwhal from First & Main is an adorable purple narwhal plush toy that is perfect for your collection.
  • Add to cart
• Quick View

  • Quick View
  • FantaZoo

  • First & Main | Koala Plush
    Fanta Zoo Keisha Koala
    10″

  • $15.99
  • Charming and colorful 10″ Koala Plush by First & Main with a lovely flower accessory.
  • Add to cart
• Quick View

  • Quick View
  • Under-the-Sea

  • First & Main | Alligator Plush
    Under-the-Sea Albino Gator
    10″

  • $15.99
  • Meet the adorable 10" Alligator Plush by First & Main. A perfect addition to any plush toy collection.
  • Add to cart
• Quick View

  • Quick View
  • Under-the-Sea

  • First & Main | Narwhal Plush
    Under-the-Sea Narwhal
    15″

  • $25.99
  • Meet the First & Main Narwhal Plush, a cozy 15" stuffed animal perfect for snuggling and imaginative play.
  • Add to cart
• Quick View

  • Quick View
  • Under-the-Sea

  • First & Main | Orca Plush
    Under-the-Sea Orca
    10″

  • $15.99
  • Meet this Orca Plush from First & Main. This adorable 10" plush toy is named Under-the-Sea Orca and is perfect for cuddling and collecting.
  • Add to cart
• Quick View

  • Quick View
  • Under-the-Sea

  • First & Main | Orca Plush
    Under-the-Sea Orca
    7″

  • $9.99
  • First & Main's Orca Plush is a 7" plush toy that is soft, adorable, and perfect for cuddling. A wonderful addition to any stuffed animal collection.
  • Add to cart
• Quick View

  • Quick View
  • Under-the-Sea

  • First & Main | Alligator Plush
    Under-the-Sea Alligator
    15″

  • $25.99
  • 15″ long Alligator Plush from First & Main - perfect for kids and collectors.
  • Add to cart
• Quick View

  • Quick View
  • Under-the-Sea

  • First & Main | Dolphin Plush
    Under-the-Sea Dolphin
    15″

  • $25.99
  • Enjoy underwater adventures with the 15" Dolphin Plush from First & Main.
  • Add to cart
• Quick View

  • Quick View
  • Under-the-Sea

  • First & Main | Stingray Plush
    Under The Sea Stingray
    10″

  • $15.99
  • Dive into fun with the Stingray Plush from First & Main, a 10" stuffed animal perfect for ocean-themed adventures.
  • Add to cart
• Quick View

  • Quick View
  • Under-the-Sea

  • First & Main | Blue Octopus Plush Toy
    Under-the-Sea Octopus
    10″

  • $15.99
  • Get your hands on the 10″ Blue Octopus Plush Toy from First & Main, featuring soft, cuddly fabric and a charming under-the-sea design.
  • Add to cart
• Quick View

  • Quick View
  • Dreampuffs

  • First & Main | Elephant Plush
    Dreampuffs™ Evie Elephant
    10″

  • $16.99
  • Cuddle up with the adorable and soft 10" elephant plush, Dreampuffs(TM) Evie Elephant from First & Main.
  • Add to cart
• Quick View

  • Quick View
  • FantaSEA

  • First & Main | Green Stingray Plush Toy
    Fanta Sea Stacy Stingray
    15″

  • $25.99
  • A cuddly and colorful 15" green stingray plush toy, perfect for kids.
  • Add to cart
• Quick View

  • Quick View
  • FantaSEA

  • First & Main | Stingray Plush
    Fanta Sea Stacy Stingray
    10″

  • $15.99
  • Meet this cute and cuddly green stingray plush from First & Main. Perfect for kids and collectors!
  • Add to cart
• Quick View

  • Quick View
  • FantaSEA

  • First & Main | Lobster Plush Toy
    Fanta Sea Laney Lobster
    15″

  • $23.99
  • Whimsical and soft, the Fanta Sea Laney Lobster plush toy by First & Main is a perfect playful companion for all ages.
  • Add to cart

10 products per page15 products per page25 products per page30 products per page50 products per page100 products per page