10 products per page15 products per page25 products per page30 products per page50 products per page100 products per page

Sort by popularity Sort by latest Sort by price: low to high Sort by price: high to low

• View:
• 100
• 200
• All

• Quick View

  • Quick View
  • Cats, Valentine's Day

  • First & Main | White Fluffy Cat Plush Cat Plush
    Fluffles Whitey Cat
    7″

  • $12.99
  • First & Main presents Fluffles Whitey Cat, a 7" white fluffy cat plush cat plush that is both cuddly and cute.
  • Add to cart
• Quick View

  • Quick View
  • Dogs

  • First & Main | Golden Retriever Stuffed Animal
    Wuffles Golden Retriever
    7″

  • $12.99
  • 7" Golden Retriever stuffed animal by First & Main. Soft, cuddly, and perfect for all ages.
  • Add to cart
• Quick View

  • Quick View
  • Baby Dreampuffs

  • First & Main | Blue Giraffe Plush
    Dreampuffs™ Raffiepuffs Giraffe
    10″

  • $16.99
  • Adorable 10" Blue Giraffe Plush by First & Main. Perfect for kids and giraffe enthusiasts.
  • Add to cart
• Quick View

  • Quick View
  • Baby

  • First & Main | Pink Teddy Bear
    Tender Teddykins
    8″

  • $12.99
  • Meet Tender Teddykins, the 8" pink teddy bear by First & Main. Perfect for snuggles!
  • Add to cart
• Quick View

  • Quick View
  • Baby

  • First & Main | Plush Fox
    Tender Friend Brodie Fox
    8″

  • $12.99
  • Adorable 8" First & Main Plush Fox, perfect for snuggling and playtime.
  • Add to cart
• Quick View

  • Quick View
  • Everyday Bears

  • First & Main | White Teddy Bear
    Eloise
    7″ Distinctive Paws

  • $12.99
  • Eloise, the 7" White Teddy Bear by First & Main, boasts distinctive paws and a lovable design.
  • Add to cart
• Quick View

  • Quick View
  • Christmas

  • First & Main | Christmas Plush Moose
    Christmas Marley Moose
    10″

  • $19.99
  • Cuddle up with the adorable Christmas Marley Moose from First & Main. This 10" brown plush moose is the perfect holiday companion.
  • Add to cart
• Quick View

  • Quick View
  • Comforting Crosses

  • First & Main | Pink Floral Pocket Cross
    Pink Floral Pocket Cross
    3″

  • $9.99
  • First & Main presents the 3″ Pink Floral Pocket Cross, a beautiful symbol of faith and devotion.
  • Add to cart
• Quick View

  • Quick View
  • Comforting Crosses

  • First & Main | Pink Floral Pocket Cross
    Multiple Blessings Pocket Cross
    3″

  • $9.99
  • Beautiful Pink Floral Pocket Cross by First & Main, a perfect daily reminder of blessings.
  • Add to cart
• Quick View

  • Quick View
  • Comforting Crosses

  • First & Main | Blue Floral Pocket Cross
    Multiple Blessings Pocket Cross
    3″

  • $9.99
  • Pocket-sized 3" blue cross with floral design.
  • Add to cart
• Quick View

  • Quick View
  • FantaZoo

  • First & Main | Tiger Plush with Purple Stripes
    Fanta Zoo Tasha White Tiger
    10″

  • $15.99
  • Adorable 10" white tiger plush with purple stripes from First & Main's Fanta Zoo collection.
  • Add to cart
• Quick View

  • Quick View
  • FantaZoo

  • First & Main | Penguin Plush
    Fanta Zoo Penny Penguin
    10″

  • $15.99
  • Fall in love with the First & Main Penguin Plush, a 10" sitting stuffed animal with a charming pink design and adorable flower detail.
  • Add to cart
• Quick View

  • Quick View
  • FantaZoo

  • First & Main | Lemur Plush
    Fanta Zoo Lena Lemur
    10″

  • $15.99
  • Adorable 10" Pink Lemur Plush from First & Main.
  • Add to cart
• Quick View

  • Quick View
  • Floppy Friends

  • First & Main | Lion Plush Toy
    Floppy Friends Leo Lion
    7″

  • $9.99
  • Adorable 7" lion plush toy from First & Main's Floppy Friends collection. Perfect for kids!
  • Add to cart
• Quick View

  • Quick View
  • Floppy Friends

  • First & Main | Otter Plush Toy
    Floppy Friends Otto Otter
    7″

  • $9.99
  • Adorable Floppy Friends Otto Otter plush toy by First & Main. This 7" brown otter plush is perfect for cuddling and playtime.
  • Add to cart
• Quick View

  • Quick View
  • Under-the-Sea

  • First & Main | Turtle Plush
    Under-the-Sea Turtle
    10″

  • $15.99
  • First & Main presents the Turtle Plush, a 10" cuddly companion perfect for your little ones.
  • Add to cart
• Quick View

  • Quick View
  • Under-the-Sea

  • First & Main | Turtle Plush
    Under-the-Sea Turtle
    48″

  • $199.99
  • First & Main's 48" Turtle Plush is perfect for marine life enthusiasts of all ages. Soft, cuddly, and beautifully detailed.
  • Add to cart
• Quick View

  • Quick View
  • Under-the-Sea

  • First & Main | Dolphin Plush
    Under-the-Sea Dolphin
    10″

  • $15.99
  • The Dolphin Plush from First & Main is a 10" cuddly toy that brings under-the-sea adventure to life.
  • Add to cart
• Quick View

  • Quick View
  • Floppy Friends, School Spirit

  • First & Main | Fox Plush
    Floppy Friends Felix Fox
    7″

  • $12.99
  • Fox Plush, a 7" plush toy by First & Main.
  • Add to cart
• Quick View

  • Quick View
  • Floppy Friends

  • First & Main | Cow Plush
    Floppy Friends Coco Cow
    7″

  • $12.99
  • Cuddle up with the delightful Cow Plush by First & Main. This 7" black & white plush animal is perfect for kids and collectors alike.
  • Add to cart
• Quick View

  • Quick View
  • Floppy Friends

  • First & Main | Elephant Plush Toy
    Floppy Friends Ellie Elephant
    7″

  • $12.99
  • Meet the Floppy Friends Ellie Elephant by First & Main. This 7" grey elephant plush toy is irresistibly cute and perfect for snuggles.
  • Add to cart
• Quick View

  • Quick View
  • Forest Friends

  • First & Main | Black Teddy Bear
    Cubby Bear
    7″

  • $12.99
  • First & Main 7" Black Teddy Bear is ideal for cuddling and gifts.
  • Add to cart
• Quick View

  • Quick View
  • Floppy Friends

  • First & Main | Hedgehog Plush
    Floppy Friends Hedgehog
    7″

  • $12.99
  • Soft and cuddly 7" Hedgehog Plush from First & Main.
  • Add to cart
• Quick View

  • Quick View
  • Under-the-Sea

  • First & Main | Stingray Plush
    Under-the-Sea Stingray
    7″

  • $12.99
  • The First & Main Stingray Plush is a delightful toy measuring 7" in length, perfect for kids and collectors alike.
  • Add to cart
• Quick View

  • Quick View
  • Floppy Friends

  • First & Main | Sloth Plush
    Floppy Friends Sly Sloth
    7″

  • $12.99
  • Bring home the 7" sloth plush, a lovable addition to your stuffed animal collection.
  • Add to cart
• Quick View

  • Quick View
  • FantaSEA

  • First & Main | Plush Lobster
    Fanta Sea Laney Lobster
    7″

  • $9.99
  • A charming 7" orange and pink plush lobster by First & Main, ideal for kids and collectors.
  • Add to cart
• Quick View

  • Quick View
  • FantaSEA

  • First & Main | Pink & Orange Crab Plush
    Fanta Sea Careen Crab
    7″

  • $9.99
  • Introducing the First & Main Pink & Orange Crab Plush, a charming 7" soft toy perfect for snuggles and playtime.
  • Add to cart
• Quick View

  • Quick View
  • FantaSEA

  • First & Main | Turtle Plush
    Fanta Sea Tallulah Turtle
    10″

  • $15.99
  • The perfect cuddly companion, the First & Main Turtle Plush is 10" long and ideal for children.
  • Add to cart
• Quick View

  • Quick View
  • Comforting Crosses

  • First & Main | Purple Stained Glass Pocket Cross
    Purple Majesty Pocket Cross
    3″

  • $9.99
  • Beautifully crafted Purple Stained Glass Pocket Cross, perfect for pocket carry or gifting.
  • Add to cart
• Quick View

  • Quick View
  • Comforting Crosses

  • First & Main | Pink Shimmer Hand Held Cross Decoration
    5.5″ | Includes Gift Box

  • $19.99
  • Elegant Pink Shimmer Hand Held Cross Decoration from First & Main, 5.5".
  • Add to cart

10 products per page15 products per page25 products per page30 products per page50 products per page100 products per page