10 products per page15 products per page25 products per page30 products per page50 products per page100 products per page

Sort by popularity Sort by latest Sort by price: low to high Sort by price: high to low

• View:
• 100
• 200
• All

• Quick View

  • Quick View
  • Horse Country

  • First & Main | Pony Plush
    Pony Domino
    10″

  • $15.99
  • An adorable 10" black spotted pony plush from First & Main, perfect for cuddling and gifting.
  • Add to cart
• Quick View

  • Quick View
  • Cats, Valentine's Day

  • First & Main | Plush Kitten
    Kit Kats
    7″

  • $24.99
  • Soft and cuddly 7" plush kitten toy by First & Main. A perfect gift for kids and cat enthusiasts.
  • Add to cart
• Quick View

  • Quick View
  • Baby

  • First & Main | Baby Blue Teddy Bear
    Tender Teddykins
    8″

  • $12.99
  • Get the adorable Blue Teddy Bear Tender Teddykins from First & Main. This plush teddy bear measures 8 inches and is perfect for cuddling and gifting.
  • Add to cart
• Quick View

  • Quick View
  • Everyday Bears

  • First & Main | Brown Teddy Bears
    Willoughby
    7″ | 2 Assorted

  • $25.99
  • Cuddle up with our cute Brown Teddy Bears, now available at a special price. Perfect for kids and collectors!
  • Add to cart
• Quick View

  • Quick View
  • Everyday Bears

  • First & Main | Brown Teddy Bear
    Bumbley Bear
    10″

  • $17.99
  • Discover Bumbley Bear, the charming 10" brown teddy bear from First & Main. Perfect for kids and collectors alike.
  • Add to cart
• Quick View

  • Quick View
  • Comforting Crosses

  • First & Main | Giraffe Print Stone Pocket Cross
    Stone Pocket Cross
    3″

  • $9.99
  • Beautiful 3" stone cross with a unique giraffe print. Handcrafted to perfection by First & Main.
  • Add to cart
• Quick View

  • Quick View
  • Comforting Crosses

  • First & Main | Stone Hand Held Cross
    5.5″ | Includes Gift Box

  • $19.99
  • A uniquely designed Stone Hand Held Cross from First & Main, perfect for prayer and reflection.
  • Add to cart
• Quick View

  • Quick View
  • Comforting Crosses

  • First & Main | Colorful Geo Mosaic Pocket Cross
    Geo Mosaic Pocket Cross
    3″

  • $9.99
  • A vibrant and colorful Geo Mosaic Pocket Cross, 3" in size.
  • Add to cart
• Quick View

  • Quick View
  • FantaZoo

  • First & Main | Frog Plush
    Fanta Zoo Felicia Frog
    7″

  • $10.99
  • Meet this delightful 7" Frog Plush from First & Main. Fanta Zoo Felicia Frog is soft, cuddly, and the perfect companion for children and frog enthusiasts.
  • Add to cart
• Quick View

  • Quick View
  • FantaZoo

  • First & Main | Monkey Plush Toy
    Fanta Zoo Mia Monkey
    7″

  • $10.99
  • Adorable 7" pink monkey plush toy with soft fur and vibrant colors.
  • Add to cart
• Quick View

  • Quick View
  • FantaZoo

  • First & Main | Giraffe Plush
    Fanta Zoo Georgie Giraffe Plush Toy
    7″

  • $10.99
  • Vibrantly colored 7" Giraffe plush from First & Main. Perfect for cuddling and gifting!
  • Add to cart
• Quick View

  • Quick View
  • FantaZoo

  • First & Main | Elephant Plush
    Fanta Zoo Elena Elephant
    7″

  • $10.99
  • Meet the Fanta Zoo Elena Elephant, a 7" elephant plush from First & Main. This adorable plush features bright pink ears and a cute purple flower detail.
  • Add to cart
• Quick View

  • Quick View
  • Under-the-Sea

  • First & Main | Pelican Plush
    Under-the-Sea Pelican
    7″

  • $9.00
  • First & Main's Pelican Plush is a soft, 7" tall toy perfect for kids and adults alike. From the Under-the-Sea collection.
  • Add to cart
• Quick View

  • Quick View
  • Under-the-Sea

  • First & Main | Penguin Plush
    Under-the-Sea Penguin
    7″

  • $9.00
  • Adorable 7" tall blue penguin plush ideal for kids and penguin lovers.
  • Add to cart
• Under-the-Sea Shark
  7""> Quick View

  • Under-the-Sea Shark
    7""> Quick View
  • Under-the-Sea

  • First & Main | Shark Plush 7″
    Under-the-Sea Shark
    7″

  • $9.99
  • 7" Gray and Blue Shark Plush by First & Main. A perfect cuddly companion for kids and shark enthusiasts.
  • Add to cart
• Quick View

  • Quick View
  • Under-the-Sea

  • First & Main | Turtle Plush
    Under-the-Sea Turtle
    7″

  • $9.99
  • First & Main's Turtle Plush Toy is a 7" cuddly companion, perfect for kids who love marine animals.
  • Add to cart
• Quick View

  • Quick View
  • Under-the-Sea

  • First & Main | Dolphin Plush
    Under-the-Sea Dolphin
    7″

  • $9.99
  • 7" blue dolphin plush by First & Main.
  • Add to cart
• Quick View

  • Quick View
  • Floppy Friends

  • First & Main | Cow Plush
    Floppy Friends Coco Cow
    7″

  • $12.99
  • Cuddle up with the delightful Cow Plush by First & Main. This 7" black & white plush animal is perfect for kids and collectors alike.
  • Add to cart
• Quick View

  • Quick View
  • Floppy Friends

  • First & Main | Giraffe Plush
    Floppy Friends Geo Giraffe
    7″

  • $12.99
  • Shop the cute and cuddly 7" Giraffe Plush from First & Main's Floppy Friends collection.
  • Add to cart
• Quick View

  • Quick View
  • Floppy Friends

  • First & Main | Fawn Plush Toy
    Floppy Friends Fawn
    7″

  • $12.99
  • Adorable 7" fawn plush from First & Main's Floppy Friends collection.
  • Add to cart
• Quick View

  • Quick View
  • Floppy Friends

  • First & Main | Tiger Plush Toy
    Tico Tiger
    7″

  • $12.99
  • First & Main's tiger plush toy, Tico Tiger, is a delightful and cuddly 7" sitting tiger perfect for children and animal lovers.
  • Add to cart
• Quick View

  • Quick View
  • Floppy Friends

  • First & Main | Plush Bullfrog
    Floppy Friends Billy Bullfrog
    7″

  • $12.99
  • Introducing the First & Main Plush Bullfrog, a charming and cuddly 7″ plush toy.
  • Add to cart
• Quick View

  • Quick View
  • FantaSEA

  • First & Main | Seal Plush Toy
    Fanta Sea Sydney Seal
    15″

  • $23.99
  • Meet this colorful and cuddly Seal Plush Toy by First & Main, 15" long, perfect for playtime and snuggles.
  • Add to cart
• Quick View

  • Quick View
  • FantaSEA

  • First & Main | Seal Plush Toy
    Fanta Sea Sydney Seal
    7″

  • $9.99
  • Meet this delightful 7" long Seal Plush Toy by First & Main. Perfect for kids and collectors alike.
  • Add to cart
• Quick View

  • Quick View
  • FantaSEA

  • First & Main | Seahorse Plush Toy
    Fanta Sea Sasha Seahorse
    7″

  • $9.99
  • Cuddle up with the First & Main Seahorse Plush Toy. This 7" plush toy is perfect for both snuggling and imaginative play.
  • Add to cart
• Quick View

  • Quick View
  • FantaSEA

  • First & Main | Manatee Plush
    Fanta Sea Maya Manatee
    7″

  • $9.99
  • Adorable 7" orange manatee plush with a cute purple flower. Ideal for cuddling!
  • Add to cart
• Quick View

  • Quick View
  • FantaSEA

  • First & Main | Dolphin Plush Toy
    Fanta Sea Daphne Dolphin
    10″

  • $14.99
  • Adorable 10″ dolphin plush toy by First & Main. Perfect for kids and collectors.
  • Add to cart
• Quick View

  • Quick View
  • Get Well

  • First & Main | Monkey Plush
    Dimples
    8″

  • $23.99
  • Adorable and soft, the First & Main Monkey Plush is the perfect plush toy for kids and collectors.
  • Add to cart
• Quick View

  • Quick View
  • Comforting Crosses

  • First & Main | Purple Hand Held Cross
    Purple Majesty Hand Held Cross
    5.5″ | Includes Gift Box

  • $19.99
  • First & Main introduces the Purple Hand Held Cross, a spiritual keepsake measuring 5.5" in height.
  • Add to cart
• Quick View

  • Quick View
  • Comforting Crosses

  • First & Main | Lamb Ceramic Hand-Held Cross
    Lamb With Cross Hand Held Cross
    5.5″ | Includes Gift Box

  • $19.99
  • Explore the Lamb Ceramic Hand-Held Cross by First & Main. A stunning 5.5" cross perfect for decoration or gifting.
  • Add to cart

10 products per page15 products per page25 products per page30 products per page50 products per page100 products per page