10 products per page15 products per page25 products per page30 products per page50 products per page100 products per page

Sort by popularity Sort by latest Sort by price: low to high Sort by price: high to low

• View:
• 100
• 200
• All

• Quick View

  • Quick View
  • Under-the-Sea

  • First & Main | Stingray Plush
    Under The Sea Stingray
    10″

  • $15.99
  • Dive into fun with the Stingray Plush from First & Main, a 10" stuffed animal perfect for ocean-themed adventures.
  • Add to cart
• Quick View

  • Quick View
  • Under-the-Sea

  • First & Main | Octopus Plush
    Under-the-Sea Octopus
    15″

  • $25.99
  • Adorable and soft 15-inch Blue Octopus Plush Toy by First & Main.
  • Add to cart
• Quick View

  • Quick View
  • Under-the-Sea

  • First & Main | Blue Octopus Plush Toy
    Under-the-Sea Octopus
    10″

  • $15.99
  • Get your hands on the 10″ Blue Octopus Plush Toy from First & Main, featuring soft, cuddly fabric and a charming under-the-sea design.
  • Add to cart
• Quick View

  • Quick View
  • Dreampuffs

  • First & Main | Plush Puppy
    Dreampuffs™ Harry Hound
    10″

  • $16.99
  • First & Main's Dreampuffs(TM) Harry Hound is a 10" white plush puppy dog. Perfect for cuddles!
  • Add to cart
• Quick View

  • Quick View
  • Dreampuffs

  • First & Main | Monkey Plush Toy
    Dreampuffs™ Chunky Monkey
    10″

  • $16.99
  • Meet the charming Monkey Plush Toy by First & Main, a 10" soft and huggable toy, ideal for kids and collectors.
  • Add to cart
• Quick View

  • Quick View
  • Dreampuffs, Valentine's Day

  • First & Main | Fox Plush
    Dreampuffs™ Foxy Roxi
    10″

  • $16.99
  • Soft and cuddly 10" fox plush toy from First & Main's Dreampuffs collection.
  • Add to cart
• Quick View

  • Quick View
  • Everyday Bears

  • First & Main | Plush Sloth
    Bumbley Sloth
    10″

  • $18.99
  • Shop the Sloth Plush by First & Main. Perfect for kids, this 10" sloth stuffed animal is cute, cuddly, and a must-have for sloth lovers.
  • Add to cart
• Quick View

  • Quick View
  • Everyday Bears

  • First & Main | Gorilla Plush
    Lonnie Gorilla
    10″

  • $17.99
  • 10" Gorilla Plush by First & Main.
  • Add to cart
• Quick View

  • Quick View
  • FantaSEA

  • First & Main | Green Stingray Plush Toy
    Fanta Sea Stacy Stingray
    15″

  • $25.99
  • A cuddly and colorful 15" green stingray plush toy, perfect for kids.
  • Add to cart
• Quick View

  • Quick View
  • FantaSEA

  • Jellyfish Plush Toy
    Fanta Sea Jenna Jellyfish
    15″

  • $25.99
  • Adorable 15" pink jellyfish plush toy with vibrant tentacles. Ideal for children and sealife enthusiasts.
  • Add to cart
• Quick View

  • Quick View
  • FantaSEA

  • First & Main | Jellyfish Plush
    Fanta Sea Jenna Jellyfish
    10″

  • $15.99
  • Get the cute and colorful 10" Fanta Sea Jenna Jellyfish plush toy from First & Main. Perfect for sea-themed collections.
  • Add to cart
• Quick View

  • Quick View
  • FantaSEA

  • First & Main | Octopus Plush Toy
    Fanta Sea Octavia Octopus
    15″

  • $23.99
  • First & Main introduces the Octopus Plush Toy, a delightful 15" plush toy perfect for kids and collectors.
  • Add to cart
• Quick View

  • Quick View
  • FantaSEA

  • First & Main | Lobster Plush Toy
    Fanta Sea Laney Lobster
    15″

  • $23.99
  • Whimsical and soft, the Fanta Sea Laney Lobster plush toy by First & Main is a perfect playful companion for all ages.
  • Add to cart
• Quick View

  • Quick View
  • FantaSEA

  • First & Main | Plush Crab
    Fanta Sea Careen Crab
    15″

  • $23.99
  • This 15" plush crab toy from First & Main is a fun and colorful addition to your stuffed animal collection.
  • Add to cart
• Quick View

  • Quick View
  • Gal Pals

  • First & Main | Blue Puppy Stuffed Animal
    Gal Pal Piper Puppy
    7″

  • $12.99
  • Meet the 7" Blue Puppy Stuffed Animal by First & Main. Soft, cuddly, and perfect for any playtime adventure.
  • Add to cart
• Quick View

  • Quick View
  • FantaSEA

  • First & Main | Seal Plush
    Fanta Sea Sydney Seal
    10″

  • $15.99
  • First & Main's Seal Plush is a cuddly and fun addition to any collection. Measuring 10".
  • Add to cart
• Quick View

  • Quick View
  • FantaSEA

  • First & Main | Alligator Plush Toy
    Fanta Sea Ally Gator
    15″

  • $23.99
  • Adorable 15" Pink Glitter Alligator Plush Toy by First & Main.
  • Add to cart
• Quick View

  • Quick View
  • FantaSEA

  • First & Main | Seahorse Plush Toy
    Fanta Sea Sasha Seahorse
    15″

  • $23.99
  • Adorable and vibrant, the First & Main Seahorse Plush Toy adds a touch of sea magic to any room.
  • Add to cart
• Quick View

  • Quick View
  • FantaSEA

  • First & Main | Seahorse Plush
    Fanta Sea Sasha Seahorse
    10″

  • $15.99
  • Bring home the magic of the ocean with First & Main's Seahorse Plush, a soft and cuddly 10" toy.
  • Add to cart
• Quick View

  • Quick View
  • FantaSEA

  • First & Main | Manatee Plush
    Fanta Sea Maya Manatee
    10″

  • $15.99
  • Adorable 10" orange sparkle manatee plush toy with pink fins and a flowery embellishment from First & Main.
  • Add to cart
• Quick View

  • Quick View
  • FantaSEA

  • First & Main | Purple Plush Turtle
    Fanta Sea Tallulah Turtle
    15″

  • $23.99
  • 15" First & Main Fanta Sea Tallulah Turtle in vibrant purple and pink.
  • Add to cart
• Quick View

  • Quick View
  • FantaSEA

  • First & Main | Turtle Plush
    Fanta Sea Tallulah Turtle
    10″

  • $15.99
  • The perfect cuddly companion, the First & Main Turtle Plush is 10" long and ideal for children.
  • Add to cart
• Quick View

  • Quick View
  • FantaSEA

  • First & Main | Dolphin Plush
    Fanta Sea Daphne Dolphin
    15″

  • $26.99
  • Adorable 15" dolphin plush by First & Main, featuring vibrant blue and green colors and a cute flower accent. Perfect for kids and collectors.
  • Add to cart
• Quick View

  • Quick View
  • Gal Pals

  • First & Main | Pink Stuffed Animal
    Gal Pals Polly Poodle
    7″

  • $12.99
  • Cuddle up with the adorable Pink Stuffed Animal by First & Main. Perfect for dog lovers and plush toy collectors alike.
  • Add to cart
• Quick View

  • Quick View
  • Jungle

  • First & Main | Gorilla Plush
    Sampson
    10″

  • $16.99
  • Meet this charming 10" Sampson Gorilla Plush Toy by First & Main.
  • Add to cart
• Quick View

  • Quick View
  • Jungle

  • First & Main | Monkey Plush
    Monty Monkeys
    13″ | 2 Assorted

  • $26.99
  • Meet this charming First & Main Monkey Plush, 13". Perfect for gifting or adding to your plush collection.
  • Add to cart
• Quick View

  • Quick View
  • Gal Pals

  • First & Main | Panda Plush
    Gal Pals Paula Panda
    7″

  • $12.99
  • Gal Pals Paula Panda, now known as the First & Main Panda Plush, stands at 7". This cute and cuddly plush is perfect for hugs and as a charming addition to any collection.
  • Add to cart
• Quick View

  • Quick View
  • Get Well

  • Monkey Plush | Get Well Soon Monkey
    Mendin. Monkey with gown
    7.5″ Sitting / 13″ Hanging

  • $12.99
  • Adorable and comforting 7.5" sitting/13" hanging Monkey Plush by First & Main. Perfect gift for loved ones.
  • Add to cart
• Quick View

  • Quick View
  • Unicorns

  • First & Main | Pink and Gold Unicorn Plush
    Magical Unicorn
    10″

  • $15.99
  • Add a touch of magic to your collection with this 10" Pink and Gold Unicorn Plush from First & Main.
  • Add to cart
• Quick View

  • Quick View
  • Unicorns

  • First & Main | Unicorn Plush
    Magical Unicorn
    7″ Standing

  • $12.99
  • First & Main's Unicorn Plush is a 7" standing soft toy featuring pink fur, golden hooves, and a glittering horn. Perfect for unicorn lovers.
  • Add to cart

10 products per page15 products per page25 products per page30 products per page50 products per page100 products per page